Where do you backup your NAS?

Hi all. Like many folks here, I run a NAS to avoid having all my personal data (and my family’s data) in the cloud. However, if you want to prepare for disaster, not just dead hardware, but the house burning down, you want an offsite backup.

Any solution that requires me or another person physically attaching external drives is doomed to fail.

Where do you backup your data? I’ve used Backblaze B2 and Wasabi for business backups, but for personal data, it starts to get pricey if you have 5-6 TB. What have you used, or where do you stick/upload your homelab NAS backups?

BTW, in my case, I’m running TruseNAS scale, with a few media shares for music and movies, and I have it running an Immich server for photos.

1 Like

I’m currently backing up to linode s3. I encrypt the backups. Works well for me and reasonably priced.

My off-site backups go to Synology C2 and Cloudflare R2 object storage.

1 Like

@monofurioso Welcome and agreed.

I use Google Drive (encrypted at rest) for critical data only (financial, legal, medical) to stay below the 5GB free tier. An alternative to paid cloud storage is to set up set up a NAS at a trusted relative’s home and enable a Tailscale MESH VPN (never expose a NAS to the public internet) between the two locations and backup between the two. Perform the initial sync on a local network, then deploy at the remotely location. This assumes both locations have sufficient bandwidth, will not incur throttling, exceed limits, or overage charges.

3-2-1 backup strategy

3 copies (original and 2 backups)

2 different types of media (offsite qualifies)

1 offsite (cloud or remote location)

I know this is the common interpretation of 3-2-1, but I implement it a bit differently. I don’t count my original data set as a copy. I keep a local copy and then two offsite copies at different providers. So I have 4 total copies of my data. And actually in my setup, I kind of have two local copies of my data. I back up my Synology locally to an Openmediavault machine that I built. But I keep two copies of the Synology. One is a “multiversion” copy so I can have version control, etc. And the other is a “single version” backup so I can actually access my data on the Openmediavault machine directly without restoring it. Its a little easier for me since my data all fits into a 1TB drive. I don’t have a media server or other large libraries of data.

1 Like

I also follow a 3-2-1 backup strategy. My main NAS is a Synolgoy, then I have a TrueNAS Frankenstein box I backup the Synology to locally. And the Offsite backup to IDrive S3 block storage for things that don’t change often and Synology C2 for things that do change rapidly.

Thanks for the insights thus far. I’m lazy, and cheap, but it does seem as if the best long term value would be to get a 2 bay NAS I can store w/ a relative, use tailscale, and store backups there.

For additional cloud backup, if I pare down to the family photos, some important document folders and my music collection, I could get away with a 1TB backup in a cloud bucket which is financially easy to swing.

I believe the Hetzner Storage Box could be a great option for you. $13 a month for 5TB or $24 a month for 10TB seems to be the lowest cost per TB in that context.

It is a shame that more NAS solutions don’t offer ways to mount external hard disks and ‘foreign’ SMB/NFS mounts.

It’s as if they expect their device to exist in isolation. The UNAS series offers cloud backup, but not really USB/portable. You can mount SMB shares. TrueNAS seems to make this difficult for the heck of it. I’ve no experience of Synology or QNAP (or others) but i’s an area they all need to work on to make easier, simpler and more flexible - it shouldn’t be ‘transparent’, but actually show the data transfer/errors.

Apologies, no use to the thread, just a rant about something pretty vital.

At least on my QNAP I can add external USB drives / HDDs and it will be seen on the NAS.

You might be shocked at all the backup mechanisms that Synology offers natively. Active backup works with Rsync, WebDAV, and Openstack Swift, all the major cloud providers (Google, Drop box, etc), any S3 provider as well as a locally attached USB volume. In addition they offer utilities to back up to Glacier, Sync (as opposed to backup) your files to any cloud provider, and to back up to other Synology NAS devices. I use Rsync to back up to Openmediavault as well as to TrueNAS

I went w/ the iDrive e2 2TB plan. $99/year for 2TB suits my backup needs, and a promo so only $50 for the 1st year. I’ll eventually setup my sister with a NAS and we can do cross buddy backups, but the iDrive fits my budget and storage needs for now. Thanks all.

An off site instance of TrueNAS. My brother’s house in my case. A little lower performance specs than my main TrueNAS machine. Less expensive case w/o hot swap bays to save a few bucks. :man_shrugging:t2:

For 5 6 TB, look for at a second NAS at another location rather than paying for cloud storage indefinitely. If you have a friend or family member willing to host a small box, you can set up replication from TrueNAS and let it run automatically. For the really important stuff like photos and documents, I would still consider keeping a smaller cloud backup as an extra layer. Media files are a different story and probably aren’t worth paying to store twice in the cloud if they can be recreated. The main thing for me would be making the offsite backup automatic. If it depends on remembering to plug in a drive every few weeks, its eventually going to get missed. :face_blowing_a_kiss:

I commenced the setup of my backup strategy over 35 years ago when my wife and I had our first son who was then relentlessly trained from a young age in the digital arts. Not quite the “quitzatzaderak” (approx) from Dune - but getting there.

So a couple of years ago his doing ok in his tech job and acquired a home NAS setup. So both of us have a fenced off section of our NAS which is “the other party’s offsite backups”. Backups use restic (with resticprofile) running over a Wireguard link which goes to my pfsense my end.

I have two locations, so I back up one location’s TrueNAS to a Synology that I’ve had forever (via RSync), and also via ZFS Replication to the second location’s TrueNAS. I have two TrueNAS servers at the second location, so I replicate location 2’s TrueNAS to the second TrueNAS there and also back to the first location’s TrueNAS. So, I have four copies of my data over two separate locations, one of which is not ZFS (the Synology).

I follow the 3-2-1 rule.

3 copies

2 different media

1 offsite (critical only)

1 Like

One addition for the buddy-backup route: make the remote copy pull-only or append-only, so a compromised source machine can’t delete or encrypt the backups too. With restic, an append-only repository plus scheduled prune from the trusted side works well; with ZFS replication, run it as a pull on the receiving NAS and keep snapshots. Also test a restore of photos and documents before trusting it. For movies and music, skipping cloud and relying on the offsite copy is reasonable.