Pfsense/Router/Tailscale

Pfsense/Router/Tailscale - sanity check and advice

Please bear in mind that I’m quite new to networking, so I might ask som really basic things…

What I have:
2 main daily driver PCs, running Server2019
2 onsite Truenases, main and backup
1 10 GB switch (Sodola)
1 Mini Pc Intel(R) Pentium(R) CPU 5405U /8GB ram/8 1GBE ports
1 Prton VPN subscription

Planned:
1 Wireless AP
1 offsite backup server Truenas trough mobile internet on reciving end

What I don’t have:
Fixed IP
Domain name
5G mobile router

I’m going to build, hopefully as much as possible on the miniPC as it is small, fan-less and power efficient for 24/7.
I would like to keep the rest off, and only on when needed, electricity is not cheep here (Ireland).

Current state:
I have built “a forbidden router” . PFsense on top of Proxmox, network adapters in passtrough.
I have installed PFsense and assigned 2GB for Pfsense and it seems to use about 20%t of it , so fine. Also processor usage seems to be low.
In total in use at the moment just under 4GB

My goal here is :
Add lightweight wiki (DokuWiki) container. Accessible from internet (Tailscale). (I have checked HW requirements and should be more than fine).
As the mini PC has 8 ports, I use one for Wan, one for Lan and I hope to put my wireless AP on one.
Set up several Proton VPN tunnels , that would be attached to a certain IP ranges.
Set up replication path between my main NAS and offsite NAS using Tailscale

I know there is a lot here, so i would like to ask is this a viable setup ?
Or am I asking for headaches?

If its viable then I would have a few questions (please tell me if you like me to open a topic for any of them, might be easier if someone later wants to use a certain part).

  1. MiniPC security, how to setup Proxmox firewall, would need to be set up so that it can only reach the update servers for itself?
    I only need to be able to configure Proxmox from local machines

  2. Tailscale How should i set it up for communication to offsite NAS?
    As my offsite truenas is built on old server HW I would like to have access to both IPMI and Truenas.
    I have been looking for examle Spitz AX (GL-X3000), that can run Tailscale locally, and has two ethernt ports, that to my understanding the port marked Wan can be configured as second lan (no need for switch).
    I want both the main NAS and my main PC’s to be able to connect to the offsite NAS. (zero trust, I sometimes download a few files from the backup to see it is accessible)
    I know that Tailscale can run on PFSense, so would it be a good option to have Tailscale on the Pfsens linking to Tailscale on the 5G router or do I need to set it up device/device?

  3. Reaching my Wiki from internet on devices not on my Tailscale network. I have heard that I could use Tailscale Funnel, to do that?
    From a security point of view,do I need to set up two Tailnets?

  4. Would it be advicable to set up VLAN’s , at the moment (before) Wiki I didn’t see a point, as I wanted all my devices to talk to eachother. But with the AP i would like 3 networks, my trusted, work and guest (maybe IOT/survailence cameras in the future.

Offsite NAS consideration:
As 5G is “slow”, I have taught that what if I can do the first backup connected to my LAN and then connect over to 5G.
Or even better use a local machine to put the first backup on a pool of disks, move the disks to the offsite machine and set up the connection ?
This would also be the way to go if the offsite machine needs full replacement. I know that I can import the disks, but what else would be needed?

Maybe there is already good answers to this, videos?

Welcome! Before I answer the questions I just wan to be clear: you’re new to networking, and this is building it on hard mode. But that is why they call this the “forbidden router” setup.

  1. I have not spent much time with Proxmox firewall, my preference is to have the management interfaces for systems, including Proxmox on a dedicated management VLAN.
  2. You can setup Tailscale on the pfsense and then it can route to the other devices.
  3. Never used Tailscale funnel my advice is not to publicly expose services if you are concerned about security.
  4. Segmenting network is important using VLANs and rules I have pfsense video here on that topic https://youtu.be/bjr0rm93uVA?si=-ClSG3n3To_B1Y0D

For the off site NAS backup, doing the backup with the device on LAN to get the initial backup done and then moving it off site would make the most sense.

For internet accessible services, I would use Cloudflare Tunnel + Cloudflare Zero Trust (just requires authentication before sending any traffic to your server(s)). Tailscale “funnel” is the same thing but a little less robust than cloudflare - which gives you a Web Application Firewall ontop of an extra layer of authentication (all free).

I have mine set to use google - so when a user hits something of mine they will be asked to sign in using their google account - it will NOT use the account in a SSO fashion so it does not pull any data from google. It simply does something akin to SAML.

It’s by no means better than a walled garden but for those things you “must” expose, it’s a very solid choice for us home-labbers.