Netgate 6100 Review?

Hello just checking in to see if maybe a Netgate 6100 review would coming out?

Eventually there will be.

3 Likes

Oh yeah! I’m looking forward to this!!! :drooling_face:

Spesh the technical breakdown on how the chip divvying out the through put on this appliance. Loved your explanations on how NetGate products do this.

What disappoints me with the 6100 is it is using exactly the same CPU as the 5100 and the 7100. It’s just a difference in RAM, drive space, and switching vs not switching that makes different outcomes on performance. But the difference in performance is always going to be constrained by that CPU because it’s such a low performant CPU (it benchmarks just above 2000). It’s a very low powered CPU and will still sit in the same class as 5100, 7100 - just different choices on the configuration of how to use that CPU. Yes, pfsense do a great job at that end of the market if all you want to do is run rulesets, NAT, and maybe an IPSEC VPN and manage to achieve different results within that using the same CPU on the different variants (5100, 6100, 7100) the 6100 does look like the better box to get - but in my view its just more of the same. If you want to run gigabit, and start to build out from that with various CPU intensive packages, the box won’t handle it due to CPU limitations.

I would have hoped that a much more powerful CPU came out and that there was something really decent that closed the big gap between the above devices and the 1357 and 1451 ie there is a HUGE gap between the 5100 / 6100 / 7100 class and the 1357 / 1451.

That’s the gap I am interested in seeing them fill plus replace the 1357 and 1451 with better CPU’s as they are six years old (well the 1541 is) and it only has a CPU benchmark of 9000 and a poor single core rating. I’d like to see much more powerful boxes that allows for CPU intensive packages to run and make the box fly, and I also have a personal choice of running desktop (silent) computers than noisy as jet engine hell of a rack mounted server :slight_smile:

1 Like

I look forward to it as it’s at the top of my wish list for wired upgrades at this time.

I do not think the cpu will present much of a problem for this build, that being said a non-atom quad or 6 core would likely provide some substantial improvements since they tend to have more cache onboard and better memory controllers.