Cloudflare Zero Trust Tunnel Issue

EDIT - found the issue, it was a TLS setting.

I am able to make the tunnel work with any device on my native lan, but not devices on my vlan. Am I doing something wrong? I will give an example below.

Native Lan -
VLan -

Public Hostname

reolink.mydomain.comhttp:// - works great
proxmox.mydomain.comhttps:// - will not work